Family Guy or American Dad?

Which one?

  • Family Guy

    Votes: 31 91.2%

  • American Dad

    Votes: 3 8.8%
  • Total voters
    34
Casanova

Casanova

I'm nothing but a beast
Veteran
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
1,950
Age
35
Location
England
Gil
0
Family Guy FTW!

It's funnier, better, funnierer, bigger AND funniererer than American Dad...which phails :monster:

American Dad FTL!

Anyone care to agree?


EDIT: someone please add a Poll with the obvious 2 options, I forgot to click the box...silly me :updown:
 
I don't agree that American Dad fails. It is still pretty funny, but I love how randomly hilarious Family Guy is. A lot of the stuff is so "WTF?" that you'd be insane not to laugh. I think that the last couple of series haven't been too great though. The characters seem to have been changing, and it isn't for the better.
 
I really liked Family Guy during its first run and I still watch the old episodes because their hilarious. When they brought it back, it just wasn't funny anymore, IMO. It seemed like they were trying to hard and not letting the jokes flow like they used to. I never really got into American Dad. I saw a few episodes and it was okay but not good enough for me to make an effort to watch it every week.

But yeah, old episodes of Family Guy are better than American Dad any day.
 
Last edited:
Family Guy definitely kills American Dad. The show was kinda funny but it never really "found itself". It ended up looking like more of a pathetic rip-off of Family Guy than anything else.
 
I like American dad just slighlty more...mainly because i find Roger to be more hilarious than Stewie, and American Dad seems to go with more adult/political humour than Family guy...

Both shows are really good though.

And about the whole rip off thing, didn't the simpsons once have an episode where they had Peter in as a homer clone?
 
Family Guy and American Dad are made by the same guy... that's why the styles are similar. Basically his one show got canceled so he made another with similar characters.
 
Family Guy by a huge margin. But Eric Cartman beats them both.
 
I prefer Family Guy for sure, I use to like American Dad more but I don't care for it so much nowadays. Family Guy is really funny and the characters in it are just plain hilarious. Stewie rules! I really like the gags they have in Family Guy, they're always witty and humorous. Some of it is a little too crude though.
 
I love American Dad, but i'm going to have to go with family guy simply because there's more seasons of it so it provides more lulz. And nobody can beat Stewie, he's one of the best cartoon characters ever. As Koloth said though, Eric Cartman ftw. Stewie is one of the best, Eric is the best.
 
Meh, I like the old episodes of Family guy. The new episodes of Family guy are fun to watch when your bored. Family Guy's jokes are getting really old. Ugh, especially the large aggressive chicken. Family Guy jokes go like this:

Peter: "Hey Louis! Remember the time when I fell down the stairs at the mall and I landed on (Insert Celebrity name)!?"

*Show clip* Then Louis comments.

I only saw one episode of American Dad, I didn't get into it.

Yes, and Eric Cartman is the best.
 
The old Family Guy is by far the best. The new episodes seem too forced, and some of the characters are losing their touch.
Unfortunately American Dad didn't develop too much either after the first series.
 
Family Guy for me. I don't watch much of it, but when I do, it's a barrel of laughs for almost every episode.

Poll Added
 
Don't really like American Dad, even for that kind of show, sometimes it is too tough to follow. I've always like Family guy though, I even bought the video game
 
I didn't use to like the new episodes of Family Guy. They were pretty stale... but I think he's gotten back into his old rhythm again. The newer or the "new" episodes are pretty good again.
 
I like the old and new episodes equally, i think they're all pretty good *shrug* So long as they dont run out of ideas for flashbacks the series will do fine, since that's ALL the jokes are is "remember when peter..." and a flashback.
 
Neither, I guess. I haven't seen American Dad, and I never will. I've seen several clips of Family Guy on youtube, and some are funny, I suppose. But not overly hilarious or anything.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top