Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Daenerys

Daenerys

The Last Dragon
Veteran
Joined
Nov 26, 2006
Messages
11,178
Age
32
Location
Suburban hell.
Gil
1
I'm starting this thread again in a more appropriate - and easier to find - section, however, as this is a post count section, posts must be more constructive than those in the last thread.

You give a rating out of 10 for both the signature and the avatar of the person above you and state why you gave that rating.

For example -

Avatar - 7/10 - Just a crop from the sig but it's been cropped in a good place and looks really good!

Signature - 8/10 - I love the mystery to this sig, you picked a great theme. The image blending is done nicely but the text lets this down a bit as it's too large.
 
Avatar - 8/10 : Though just a crop, it's still a fairly decent image, and I quite like the pattern effects.

Sig 1 - 8/10 : Though I love the pattern effects, I don't like the bland white areas. But that's my only gripe.

Sig 2 - 9/10: Not a huge fan of Pikachu, but I love what Mark has done here. And I think the spark effects, well, what I think are spark effects, are pretty damn nifty!
 
Avatar - 6/10 : It looks cool, but I'm not really sure what it is...?

Sig - 8/10 : I like how it's just circles and I like the colors, but it's hard to see what it actually is.
 
6/10 - It's a crop from the original, but the added text to it is good.

7/10 - I like the colors in this. Unique. Not a fan of the texture of it though. It makes it look rough.. and a little blurry.
 
Avatar: 7/10
I thought it was a little too simple. Looked like some change in contrast or something. The wordings were okay though.

Signature:6/10
I think you could have used a more images. That signature's made up of only 1 picture right? You seemed to have used merely different parts of it.
 
Avatar - 5/10 I like the text and the scorpion, but too much white space for it to be really outstanding ><
 
Avatar: 10/10
I really like the colors and the textures in it as well as the gradients.

Sig: well since there are 2
sig1: 10/ 10 I like the same things about it as the avatar

sig2: It may be simple, but in its simplicity its really really pretty. I like the text and i like the colors
 
Avie and Sig= 8/10

I really love the colors and lighting on both of these. I also love it when users use a set, instead of a different Avie + a different picture. Though this is simple, it's still beautiful.

Though, it may be a bit TOO simple for my liking. ;)
 
Celes like the new sig and avy!

Avy - 9/10 - Great (and most iconic) pic of Celes, and with the text to go with it.

Great. Sig - 9.5/10 - Fantastic pic (again), great colour scheme and nice quote from the opera.
 
Avatar - 7/10. I dislike the white space, but I like the picture ^^

Signature - 6/10. It's a pretty picture, I like how it looks all Spanish and authentic ^^ I like the text work too =]
 
Signature 8/10 I like the colours, fits nice with the render, nice beldning, dont like the b&w brushing so much

Avatar 5/10 its just a cut of your signature.
 
Avatar: 5/10
The text is pretty unclear and the chosen colours aren't the best either.

Signature: 10/10
The sig is a masterpiece, you better put it in SOTW or you won't be so cheerful anymore :monster: (And I will be the reason behind it)
 
avi 7/10 it looks a bit blurry to me

sig 6/10 too small for my tastes but very well done
 
Avatar: 9/10 - Loving it. The colors and soft look to it really did it for me.

Signature: 7/10 - I don't know why, but I like the white space in tags. As far as GFX skills though, I see very little, but overall it's still very nice to look at.
 
Avatar: 9/10 - I've always loved that butterfly avatar. =P It's simple yet quite clever, and I enjoy it a lot.

Sig: 10/10 - I don't know what's wrong with this. The image is blended very well, the colors are satisfying, the text is great. Excellent job, Mits. :monster:
 
Avatar - 8/10 nice and bright, also very clean and sharp

sig 7/10 again the same as above but theres a little too much bland space imo. I think it looks better as an avatar.
If i was to scroll down the page though your av and sig would pop out at me. Thats a plus :)
 
7/10 for the avatar and the sig. Like the colours, can't really see the text in the sig all that well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top