SOTW 125 Voting

[Six]

Theme: Preset Render

1.

2.

3.

* Entrants are not allowed to vote for their own entries.
* Posting feedback along with casting a vote is highly encouraged.
* Voting ends in 7 days.
* Please do not give away the creators of the entries, appropriate actions will be taken.

 

[greenyxi]

They're all really noice, but 3 went a bit more creatively and literally went outside of the box. 3 gets my vote just for being different .

 

[Six]

My vote goes to #1.

The only thing I would've changed is the main text, and remove the glow it has, it makes it seem a bit messy. Aside from that, very good pick for the background in this one. I do suggest blending the render in a bit more next time.

2: Could've used some more effects, perhaps the darkness on the left could've been brightened up a little as well.

3: Though creative, I'm not a big fan of the random clipping masks. They don't seem to suit the piece as they come from behind the circle. Good colour, and I believe the render was used in the background as well which is nice. Same as 1, I do suggest blending the render in a bit more next time.

 

[The Witch]

Wow, you are guys are more talented then me... I tried over and over again to use this render and it all came out like shit.

All three are gorgeous;

I instantly liked looking at this tag. The colors are executed very well, I like the foggy look combined with the green egg-like structures in the back, it makes me feel like I'm on an Alien planet. The only thing I don't like is the grey drop-shadow behind the text, and the font chosen. I like the placement and the use of secondary font, but the green and yellow text really makes it contrast with the left side and the focal, which is a turn off.

This one is very pretty. I love how glossy it is, I love the colors chosen, too. My only complaint is the text takes the focal-point away from the render. My eyes are going to the gorgeous font as apposed to the render. I love what you did with the text, but it's too in your face. I'm not sure how one would fix that.... Oh, I also really like how this one made me feel like I was looking at a robot. The cool silver tones really capture a theme and I'm glad the artist stuck to that.

Anyway,

I love the colors used, they're true to the render, while looking glossy. I LOVE the font and text placement, including that decorative detail. It continues this very robotic theme. Like the first signature, it comes off more like an alien tag than a robot tag, though. I also really like the splatter brushes used on its edges, my only suggest is that there should have been more or placed differently. I also give props to the artist for taking a risk and doing a different shaped signature.


All that said, I'm gonna have to go with the best made signature that captured the theme properly... and that is signature #2.

 

[Six]

Congratulations to Dyranda and Galadín for winning this week's SOTW!

1: Dyrana (3 votes)
2: Six (0 votes)
3: Galadin (3 votes)

Thanks to everyone who voted & participated in this week's competition.
Don't forget to check out the guidelines for the upcoming SOTW!
​