SOTW 138 Voting Thread

SOTW 138

  • Total voters
    25
  • Poll closed .
Daenerys

Daenerys

The Last Dragon
Veteran
Joined
Nov 26, 2006
Messages
11,178
Age
32
Location
Suburban hell.
Gil
1
The theme this week is Nature. Please remember, that while posting isn't necessary in order to count your vote, it is encouraged.

Also, please remember that you CANNOT vote for your own entry, and you will be disqualified from this SOTW, and the next two SOTWs if you do so.

Here are the entries I received:

1)

wk03kl.jpg


2)

e8ph5k.jpg


3)

bamboosig.png


4)

141hxt5.png


5)

Save_The_Seals_Banner_by_CaliforniaBabeWV.png

 
Four was beautiful, with the bird and the flowers blending in beautifully with one another, while being recognisable on their own. Great work.
 
Ahhhh torn between 2 and 4.

I really like them both, loveing the image used on 4, but i think its just a little too bright in the middle for my liking, right over the parrot as well, which should be all vivid and it kinda takes away from that, thats the only thing I dont like either

Number 2 gets my vote, loving the butterfly and the effects are gorgeous, the colours are nice as well, there's nothing i can pick at of thisone that I dislike, so this one gets it from me
 
NUmber 1 was the only one of the bunch that appealed to me.
It has the best depth out the lot and although i feel its maybe just that bit too green its a tag i really like. Nice simple approach but i think its been executed really nicely. I think actually had the lighting filter been used it coulda improved it but its a nice piece anyway :)
 
I voted for #1.

It stood out beautifully.

The colours are all so rich and really represented the theme well.

It feels nice and relaxed and I really love that red patch over on the left. It's so rich and gives it more colour.

The black half border really finishes this one off nicely too. <3

Great work to everyone else!
 
I liked 2.

Its looks very clean and the butterfly looks really elegent and the background pops out IMO and its a very great siggy. The colors used are fantastic and they really go well together.
Nicely done =]
 
My votes going for number 5. It melts my heart and I adore seals. The image is just so sweet and I love how the text catches your attention with the rainbow behind it. <3 seals, this has cheered me up. Thanks whom ever did this <3
 
Colours of 4 are amazing. also the lightning fits perfectly in it,

2 was also very nice,

but i vote for 4, nice work!
 
My vote goes to number 4.

1. I loved, the nice blending and colouring are gorgeous. I love the shade of brown red over to the left, and how the path alone gives that "mysterious, where does this lead" feel to it. Text was really nicely tucked into the corner, and even though I prefer text a bit more towards the middle, this works nicely.

The subtle lining under it looks gorgeous.

2. This is an amazing signature, but I personally don't feel the negative space on both sides. I think had this signature been smaller, it would've made up for it's gorgeous futures. There was no text, which made this tag better as a whole, 'cause the image alone speaks for itself, but... yeah. The size I'm sticking on.

4. Gorgeous. Though the sudden outburst of colours in the 'tropical green' feels a bit random, but you'd be surprised with the colours there in real life. xD It really caught my eye right away, the colours are beautifully picked, and the parrot compliments them amazingly. I love the lightning, though I think the green above the parrot maybe should've been a bit darker, seeing the light source was attempted to come from the front I think.

Text is really nice. Eye candy sig so to speak. :ryan:

5. I love how this one was different from all of them. The appearing simple tag, really has great detail actually.

The brush and light work really gives it that "harsh sun lightning" on to the baby seal, which I really liked.

The text was a tad big, but over all effective.


--

Awesome entries this week! :D
 
My vote goes to #1, but I feel like I have a poor taste in art when my votes are with the minority...but perhaps that is just the small, exceptional group with very good taste in art...another way of looking at it anyways. xD

Love all the greenery, and the red to the left side of the sig is very appealing, and that which looks like steps in really cool, that represents the path you take, be it between the lush plant life, through, or over. In this case it is between, surrounding by all the pretty nature around. ^_^
 
  • Like
Reactions: Six
#2 gets my vote. Out of each entry, it stood out the most and brought out the theme.
 
I voted for 5.

I did like 1 but the colouring wasn't to my taste. I just seemed too powerful and the transition between the green and red/orange wasn't subtle enough.

I thought the text in 5 was good and I'm not going to lie... I know who made No.5 but I did genuinely think it was the best. I really like this style of signature... even though the depth could be improved upon. (Although, it's not like people DON'T know who made each signature.)
 
I voted for #3. They're all really beautiful, but for me whenever I think of nature, I picture very green, secluded places, and this one creates that atmosphere really nicely ^_^
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top