SOTW 70 Voting Thread!

SOTW 70 Voting Thread

  • Total voters
    21
  • Poll closed .
Daenerys

Daenerys

The Last Dragon
Veteran
Joined
Nov 26, 2006
Messages
11,178
Age
32
Location
Suburban hell.
Gil
1
The theme for this week was Scooby Doo! Remember, you have to post for your vote to count ^^

1)

2diew47.jpg


2)

2865x.jpg


3)

sc.png
 
The first one was all right but the render wasn't blended enough for me to think it the best. The second was really good but looks relatively simple. The last of the three entries grabbed my vote for the reason that real people are much more difficult to work with and it's obvious that so much more effort was required for the latter sig.

#3
 
Hmmm scooby Doo oh I hate this show but entry number 1 is very nice I like the colors used there. Well yeah so I guess my vote will go to entry number 1.
 
1. it was really good looking. If I was to put any of them in my sig it would be this one.
2. Old school, but looks heartless.
3. I hated how it looks.
 
ScoobyDoo, that's random :P
I wish to vote for number 2. The colours are playful and the all of the characters are placed in it. I really love it.
 
#1 - incorperates great color use, although the text/stock placements and blending are poor.

#2 - effects are not very favorable, in my opinion. The text is also out-of place, and the focal point is all screwed up; all elements of the tag just point to the left [lolsubliminalbeyoncereference] instead of to a point.

#3 - I give the creator credit for being able to maintain a good flow with such a difficult stock. The colors and text are also favorable.

Go 3!
 
Last edited:
Voting for #1

I like the render used, small text, the background used as its nice and it fits the render perfectly.
 
Voting for 3.

I like the cloudy effect in the background and the colours go very well with the render. The Sig seems very 70's inspired.
 
1 gets more vote.

The sharp image coupled with the effects looks good and attracts the eye well, the background effects look colorful and playful like the show actually is.
 
Number one is cute ( yea i said cute ) it stands out far more than the other 2 and has has a simple cartoon-ish feel to it.
 
My vote goes to #1. I love how the picture of Scooby and Shaggy is blended in behind the text; that's very clever. All in all, I think it's a really cute siggie ^.^
 
It would have been number 1 for me but the subject placement didn't appeal to me at all. Granted, it's a pretty signature with a nice color theme and cute text, but overall it just looks a tad bit off.

So I went with number 3 due to its soft look and great composition. The color theme is cute as well and the clouded effects worked out nicely. The text is so-so...I thought it could have been better, but it's not too bad either.
 
I just love 1 so much! The colors with the brushes all go perfect with Scooby and the image has been placed in a well chosen position! Love it!
 
It was really difficult to make up my mind on this one. It was between 2 and 3 for me. I had a really difficult time deciding which one I liked more, but in terms of overall quality on them, I decided to go with 2. It actually set itself apart from the others, and even though the composition isn't that great, the effects are better than the others for me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top