Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well if you have photoshop you can make the guy in the sig bigger. Maybe you can find someone who can do it for you? Just find a nice sized image and ask a GFXer to crop it or something. I'll do it for you if ya want!

Avi:7/10
sig:8/10
 
Avi 8/10

i like the avi more then the sig i dunno why but it fits the sig so

sig 7/10

i think you should add some more to it
maybe do somthing with the texture

but nice work ;p
 
Avatar: 10/10

It's a great avatar. It's simple, and the colours are great and vibrant. The goddess of text really did well with the text, too. It's a great avatar. The border completes it quite well, too.

Sig 5/10

The background is quite good. But the render just looks pasted on. He isn't blended in, and the background's colors don't complement him very well. You could have done much more to Broly to make him seem as though he was actually in the signature, not on it. Like use a Gradient map or something. Look up some blending tutorials and signature tutorials to get better at blending. The font is slightly too big and the color is wrong, too.
Much more could be done to this piece.
 
Ava: 8/10
Sig: 9/10

I love how the two sig pictures contrast in colour, I think it looks brilliant and it definitely catches the eye. They're edited really well and they blend it, awesome stuff.
The avatar is good too I'm just a fan of bigger avatars. ;]
 
avatar= I say about...5 because it seems to be just a stock image slapped on as an avvy...

Sig= 5 for the same reason. Go to the request section and get yourself a custom avatar sig set :monster:
 
@squee

av 4/10 not bad but the text and colouring could be looked over to bring it together in a more eye pleasing way everything clashes.

sig - 3/10 again the colours need sorted and the image is oversharpened in areas that it neednt be. Try to stick to 2 colours, preferably ones that compliment eachother
 
Avy: 3/10 Im not a fan of sigs with real people in them, although the face he's making is kinda funny.

Sig: Again im not a fan of sigs with real people in them, and i dont even know who it is. 2/10
 
Avi: 5/10
It's got too many things going on. I don't really know what's going on to the left of it though I do like the right of the avi alot more...

Sig: 7/10
I like the sig but it's kinda plain. It seems like all it's got going for it is the Vanille image on either side, although I like the whole concept of it. The text below her name is way too small to read. It's very cutesy and I kinda like it.
 
Avatar: Pretty basic, nothing wow about it. It seems to plain and boring for me. 3/10

Sig: It needs something else added. But what, Im not sure. Text could be different font, but the colours go well with the image. 5/10
 
Avatar: I'll give it a ten, I like Matt Bellamy from Muse.

Signature: I'll rate it a ten too, for the same reason :P
 
Avatar : 5/10

Just seems to be a crop with some brush effects added. The effects further make the avatar look monotone and dull looking. Perhaps a cleaner, more vibrant looking stock could have been used. She looks either sharpened too much or drawn, either way, looking very dull.

Sig 4/10

Just seems to be Lady Gaga put onto a gray background/gradient. Nothing special about it, but nothing wrong with it, either. Could have been better if there were effects or brushing. It seems too big, too. Too much space that takes away from the focal, which should be Miss Gaga.
 
Avi: 6/10
I like the picture, but not too fond of the text, too bold for my liking, could possibly try to blend it in?

Sig: 8/10
I'm going for the bottom sig as I like it more than the top one :) I like the colours and the font is decent too.
 
Icon: 8
It's too blurry, but I like the affect used and the font.

Banner: 9
It's too blurry but other than that, I love it. Great placement of the words too. Good job.

You should try to save the files as a PNG so it doesn't look blurry anymore. :)
 
Avy+Sig 1 and 2= 10/10

Avy: It's way too adorable. Text is perfect and goes well with the avy well.

Sig 1: I love the picture! The text is is so fitting, the same with your avy, and I love how "chocobo" and "love' are different colours too. You chose a good quote too.XD

Sig 2: .......Wow. It took me a long time to figure out who that was. I haven't laughed this much all this week.XD
Anyway, I like the duplicate images and in a way, it's dark and vibrant at the same time. I really like the little light orbs floting around the text and the border finishes it off nicely. Great sigs!<3
 
Avvy = I give it a 4, it looks so simple, almost like a stock image, I'm not sure really...It could use some tweaking

Siggy = 3, it doesn't work well at all, it doesn't have a focal point, and again seems like a stock image. It's also very simple if it isn't a stock picture, so I give it a 3...
 
The avi gets a 7. It's flashy but I feel like something is missing...it's a good avi though...

Siggy 1 gets a 9. It's just stunning...

Siggy 2 gets a 7. It's kinda nice though I believe if you took in the sides a little more, it would be better. The images work nice though it would be nice if you could have the enlarged image of the guy move a little away from the little one in my opinion...
 
Avatar: 8/10

As an avatar, it look very good. The crossing keyblades (;3) look very cool and don't block his face, which is very good. The blow brush used for the background looks very good and adds to the avatar.

Sig : 8/10

As a sig, now, it doesn't work as well as the avatar, but it still looks great. The effect that the glow brush gives makes the piece look very good. I like the crossing keyblades and the word Roxas going between them. Roxas is blended in well, but those brush strokes on him looks very un-professional. Otherwise, this signature looks great. Roxas could have been a tad smaller, though :hmmm:

Great Job!
 
Icon: 8
Been an FFIX fan since I witnessed its awesomeness. Kudos to the creator of the avatar

Sig: 9
Cloud looks great on this pic, and the background is a nice touch. Bravo.
 
Avi: 8
Nothing special about it and the style and shape is different.

Siggy: 8

Same, nothing special too it really...
 
Lol I should be getting some sleep! I'll leave just after this!

Avy gets a 7. It seems plain and just not appealing to me :/.

The sig however gets a 9. It's very interesting and it may seem plain at first but it really captures and hold my eye. One thing I would mention is the small text should be bigger in my opinion. I cant read it and it makes me feel left out of some kind of secret wisdom... other than that I likey the siggy!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top