Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nathan Drake said:
I quite like the background, it is like a painting almost, granted I have no idea what it originally looked like so maybe it is a painting. The colours and style suit the image nicely, though it could have been blended more I suppose. Or maybe not, it looks pretty great as it is
Click to expand...

na i made it look like a painting :) here the stock image

haru.jpg


anyway on your set... i quiet likw it.. the way the signature is done is nicly done :).... the avatar a bit simple but loving the signature.. avatar 8/10 signature 9/10
 
As Conor said, the background is really cool with that painted look. It's nice to see the original picture to compare it to. You did a good job, I am not really loving the picture of the girl though, it seems all the effort went into the background but the girl just kind of looks plain :( The text is nice and cute though.

8/10
 
Back to rating sigs, like I usually do.
-

Avatar - 7/10. Very simple, I like that. Nothing more to say.

Sig 1 - 7/10. It's odd honestly. You have a light source, but it doesn't seem to compliment any area of the signature. The colours are a bit too dull for my like, however, I do like the sharpness of the piece.
 
A bit too simple for my tastes. I mean, the lighting is nice, but sadly that's all it has going for it :/. The text is nice, though. So, I guess that lands you some cool points. 6.7/10

And the matching avvy is just a crop, so... 6.5/10 - my default rating.
 
For your Candace set I think it looks good. The blending is really great and the color and tint of the sig helps it stand out. I think it works much better as a signature than an avi. 8/10

You second sig gets a 9/10 for its impressive blending of noctis and the effects. The color in it is very eye catching.
 
I know you had issues making it its proper size, and my only real complaint is that it is a bit small :lew: So besides that, it's a very nice set, I like the little white glowy thingies. And Bahamut looks really nice against that background.

8.5/10

Just saying, but since it is very small it may look better if you center the sig into the middle of your post. Just a suggestion ^_^
 
The sig is nice. Nice tones of blue and violet, and they match so well. The flowers seem a bit out of place, though. :/ Still, it's nice. 7.5/10

Love the avvy, but not liking the text in it. :( 7.3/10

7.4/10 overall.
 
Sig 1: 7/10, I like that you're still going with the shaded lightning you've been doing in most of your recent sigs. Now if you could just sharpen the image up a little bit, and make the text stand out, rather than blended in with the background.

Sig 2: 8.5/10. This one I like better, I like that you put the effort into using C4Ds. Good execution, but the lower left hand side is just a bit too messy. Also, your text is a major improvement on this one, try adding a soft drop shadow layer behind it.

Avatar: 7/10 a good crop out, but it needs need to be sharpened, and brightened more.

---

Now mind you, before you rate my sig, it's a rotating sig, so make sure to state which one you're rating.
 
Will Rate as a set. :grin:

I saw this on your profile earlier and instantly thought :ohoho: amazing!
I really like it a lot I think it's a great picture used and I like the lighting and the cut out on the right side there, I'm a bit of a fan of the squarer shaped sigs so that works in favour for me as well. I know not everything needs it but perhaps some text could have done it a little more justice or even a border.

9.5/10 :inlove:

Oh yes, my bottom sig rotates so yeah, state which one it is you're rating. etc etc etc.
 
Kyoshiro Seiji said:
Sig 1: 7/10, I like that you're still going with the shaded lightning you've been doing in most of your recent sigs. Now if you could just sharpen the image up a little bit, and make the text stand out, rather than blended in with the background.

Sig 2: 8.5/10. This one I like better, I like that you put the effort into using C4Ds. Good execution, but the lower left hand side is just a bit too messy. Also, your text is a major improvement on this one, try adding a soft drop shadow layer behind it.

Avatar: 7/10 a good crop out, but it needs need to be sharpened, and brightened more.

---

Now mind you, before you rate my sig, it's a rotating sig, so make sure to state which one you're rating.
Click to expand...

My whole idea with the first sig was to do something original, including the text. I suck at text mainly, so I wanted to blend it in. So, please don't take this as a way of me responding harshly to your comment or anything, I just though I should clarify what my intent on it was. ^_^

@Toni: Since I made your avvy and sig, I'll rate the one that Lew did.

I like it, and the smudging is good, but i think it's a bit over-used. :hmmm: Still, I like the contrast between colors. 7.8/10
 
Zipper said:
The sig is nice. Nice tones of blue and violet, and they match so well. The flowers seem a bit out of place, though. :/ Still, it's nice. 7.5/10

Love the avvy, but not liking the text in it. :( 7.3/10

7.4/10 overall.
Click to expand...

How can you say the flowers are out of place :ahmed: He's giving me those flowers Ken! Because he loves me =3

Okay.

Avi- It's very well done. The lighting and text is nice. Sadly, I personally don't like it too much, I don't know why. But really it is quite nicely done.
8/10

Michelle Sig- Wow. This is really good. It reminds you of nighttime, and I love the city landscape.
9/10

Noctis Sig- Love it. Having Noctis in it itself makes it great, and I love the text and the red. It looks like he's holding a chainsaw :lew:
 
The avatar is quite good I suppose, not too mad on the big purple background. The text is odd, I can't read it which is annoying, but it ties the image together nicely. It is very nice altogether, but I am not really sure of the technical reasons are that make it aesthetically pleasing to me. Too much purple though, far too much

I do not like the signature too much, the effects and all are nice, as well as the image and all that jazz. It just looks out of focus or something, with random sharp bits here and there, bu daz juz me man
 
Avatar:

I like the avatar. The colours are rich and I like splash of red down the bottom. Simple but nice.

10/10

Signature:

Personally I think the shape of the signature is a bit out there. I think it's too tall for the width. I like rectangular shapes more than squares for signatures. Other than that I like the rich colours and the lighting. I think that it could of used some text and a border but other than that it's well done. =)

8/10
 
I absolutely love this set! :D The colours and effects are absolutely gorgeous! I really love the vectors and lighting. The composition is also fabulous, with Tidus sitting very nicely behind Yuna. :) Excellent work!

Oh, I think the sig benefits from the lack of text too! :)

The avatar is nicely chosen from the sig too! :D

9.5/10 for both.
 
I like your other yuna sig better D:

but hey,this has some nice fractal and C4D action going on. Not so keen on the border as it doesn't really go with my personal taste, but whatever. The text is nice. 7.8/10

Like the avvy, but those dots on her face do not flow with me well D:. 6.8/10
 
Avi: 5/10

It's really small, so can't see much of it, but from what I can see, the focal doesn't really seem to fit in with the surroundings.

Sig: 6/10

I like the colour of this one, and the lines on the sides are a nice touch, not sure what is really going on in the sig though, and the text could probably blend in more with the sig.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top