Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avvy: 7/10, nice and simple,though needs some work on the text.

Siggy: I'll rate it later, because i'm at school now and the internet has photo bucket blocked

EDIT: 7/10 i dunno, just looks like it needs something more. Work n ur bg, it doesnt look well with the render and i'm thinking some text??? I dunno...
 
Last edited:
Avatar:
The colours work great! The only issue I have is how bright the lighting in the upper right corner is.
8/10

Sig:
Very attractive brush work! And Tifa coming off the background is just an awesome idea!
9/10
 
avatar - 5/10 the colours are a tad dull and im not fon of the filters around her.

sig - 9/10 love it! Great use of resources and clipping and simple yet exceedingly effective colour scheme. Great Tag.
 
Avi: 9 / 10 Ver nice. Like the colours used.

Sig: 9.5 / 10 OMG I just love the effects in the BG. The flames as well. ONOM-ish.
 
Av: 9/10 nice background, good contrasts

Sig: 9/10 the background and the foreground goes well together, makes me wish I could do this stuff.

(Can you rate my sig please, my avatar is not my own design.)
 
Sig=7/10. It's very simple, but nice. Aside from the image, your signature is very busy, but that's not a bad thing in this case. =D
 
Sig = 7/10 The text is done relatively well, and the hearts look cute. ^__^ However, I don't like the 3 focal point setup. Sorry. ^_^;;

Avatar = 8/10 Eva rocks! Almost as much as Wolf did in MGS1. :P
 
Avatar: 3/10

It looks like it was cropped and then reduced in size from the signature, which then lowered the quality of the image.

It's a bit sketchy and a bit dull. I would suggest starting from scratch on this avatar with the original image, as it looks distorted from the decrease in size.

Signature: 5/10

This one looks better and much clearer than the avatar.

I like the filters used for the background but I don't think the effects surrounding her were necessary. It tends to make it a tad messy looking and overcrowded.

The text looks nice though I think it should be placed closer to Rinoa and have some light added to it. It's a bit hard to see at the moment.
 
Avatar / Sig: 10/10


They compliment each other very well, and the color scheme is brilliant. I can't really find anything wrong with what I see. Fascinating. Wonderful job!

(A little about my sig/av, they were my first attempts at editing, and I really had no idea what I was doing, so that's why they didn't turn out like masterful works of art. xP)
 
Last edited:
its ok, i totally understand =D

Avvy: 8/10
Colour scheme is really good and stands out verry well! I like it!

Siggy: 6/10
A bit too big for my liking, and the stock doesnt really stand out much, imo. the text, howeber is awesome and the effects are really nice! Good job for your first time!
 
All right, I'm going to do this again, since I took another shot at making a sig. The second image I don't know, I kind of liked it I guess.

Anywho, onto the rating.

Avatar: 9/10 I like how you made it different from the signature, as well as making the wings stand out. It makes it look clearer than if you had just cropped it.

Signature: 9/10 I'll also give this one a 9 because I think the colors compliment each other, and I can tell you put some thought into it. Good job!
 
Avatar: 8/10.
I like its, its very simple and clean as an avatar would be, its not an ever sore and not too fancy.

Signature 1: 6/10
The colors are too bright I'd say, maybe like a little too noisy and it seems as if they're simply everywhere. The render is well placed and all but that yellow ray going over it doesn't look right to me. The size I don't mind seeing as how it was used.

Signature 2: 7/10
A lot of the same details of the first one apply to the second one, the color scheme seems outta control, the patters go from right to left and left to right, it looks a little messy I'd say. Again, the size doesn't bother me seeing as how the space was used. The text doesn't bother me too much either seeing as how it matches the messy nature of the background.

No worries keep practicing. =)
 
Last edited:
Avvy 9/10

I like it, it makes me...think. the Xs on the side make it more mysterious and i love the 2 lines you got there...verrry nice.

Siggy1 8/10

I like this peice a lot, especially the brush work. The blending was very well done and you have a nice simple border to top it off. good job

Siggy2 10/10

I love this one, simply awesome! The colour scheme, the text, the brush work its all like omg. The only thing im not fond of is the lens flare as lighting, but thats just me, you actually pulled it off very well

Nice job!
 
Avatar - 7/10; The only problem with it is that the girl is cut off a little too much. Otherwise, I really like it!
Signature - 8/10; The signature is a lot better. The girl isn't cut off too much, and it has a collage feel to it that you don't get with the avatar. The words help, too.
Nice combo!
 
Avatar 8/10
Signature 9/10

This is the first Genesis avatar and signature that I saw in this forum. The colors are great but it is kind of too light.
 
Last edited:
Avatar: 9/10
Mitsuki always makes amazing stuff, and this avatar is no exception. Vlack and white is always simple and could never go wrong and then the black border makes it even better. =)

Signature: 10/10
Again, Mitsuki makes some amazing stuff and the signature look so awesome. =) I'd have to say that the text is my favorite part of the entire piece. <3
 
Avatar - 9/10; It's so simplistic, but it works so well and I really like it! ^^ What make it the most I think is the itty bity dark text in the corner. It might not seem like much but it pulls it together.
Signatures - 10/10; I don't think I could ever make signatures that well. I am a master of bright and foggy, and not crisp and clear. Though I am trying to master both. ^^ The letters in the second one is fantastic! How do you do that???
 
Avatar: 6/10

In my opinion, this would look a lot better if the image were clearer.

It looks a bit scratchy and blurry at the moment.

I like the text at the top left hand corner and the border and the little symbol look great too!

Signature:

Same as before. It would look a lot better if the image were higher quality.

Other than that I like the symbol in the top left hand corner, though I think you should take away the line of text, which says 'Genesis' that goes on an angle at the top.

One line of text is enough down the bottom.

Nice blending and the colour scheme looks great!

Good lighting also.

8/10
 
(I made myself a new avatar/signature! ^^ I like to make them a lot so mine may change quite often...)

Avatar - 9/10; It would be cooler if there were more effects added to it or a border or something, but Nice! xD

Signatures - Fantastic! Theres cool effects added to them and the color schemes go well together! The texts on them I think are very nice. 10/10
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top