Rydia vs Rosa

[HRBN]

Not by popularity...

Note: Rosa has a bow and the small dagger you see on the DS opening.
Rydia has her whip.

Location: Lunar Subterrane

Starting Distance: 20m

who wins?

 

[HolyDragoon]

Rosa
Cast Paralyze/Hold, then Reflect on self.
Cast Silence for good measure.
Pelt Rydia with arrows until she dies.

Rydia maybe gets off a weak fire spell before being paralyzed.

 

[Onion Knight]

Rydia:
Cast stop on Rosa and get a headstart.

 

[HolyDragoon]

Stop is a slower cast time though.

(PS Rydia wins my popularity contest, I was being practical.)

 

[Thomas_87]

Think I have to go with Rosa on this. Basically she only needs to cast silence to make all Rydias spells worthless. Followed up by Haste on herself and slow on rydia. Rydias whip can paralyze but I think that Rosa will be the winner nevertheless.

 

[Milia]

if summons and magic can be used Rydia would win. If it's only weapons & physical combat then Rosa wins. As for who I like best out of these two, Rosa, not that I have anything against Rydia.