SOTW 184 Voting

[Six]

Theme: Pokemon

1.

2.

* Entrants cannot vote for own entries.
* Voting ends in 7 days.
* Posting feedback while voting is greatly appreciated.
* Late entrants have 24 hours as of this post to submit entries.

 

[Lirael]

1
The use of colour in this is fantastic. The pink flowers really suit Jigglypuff's personality and appear to be part of a scene, in which Jigglypuff is admiring them. The lighting you have used helps to bring the piece together, and I really like the fact you've used the brown in the branches as the colour of 'Pokemon.' The font used for 'Jigglypuff' also suits the Pokemon's personality and type. To improve, think carefully about the framing of your work. You have lost the bottom of Jigglypuff and I feel this sig would have been better had you fit the entire render into the piece and perhaps created a ground for him/her to stand on.

2
I absolutely LOVE the colours in this and the use of a black background. The flowers, butterflies and splashes suit Ivysaur's Pokemon type and bring out his/her pink flower. The lighting helps to bring it all together; without the lighting, the background would have looked quite flat against the 3D render. The text you have used is also well placed and the use of dots and a line works incredibly well. To improve, you could have used a border as this sig gets lost on the current background, and I feel it a neat rectangle (possibly in white) around the edge would help make this piece feel 100% complete.

Both of you are clearly very talented, but the use of colour and the framing of 2 just about won me over.

 

[Jake]

The colours in the second one are really striking. First thing I noticed when I opened the page. Love it! I dunno what it is though but I can't help but see the Pokemon as a separate thing on top of the background. Maybe it's the feet? Anywho, for that reason I'mma vote for the first entry this week. I just like how it all fits together a bit more.

Both are great though!

 

[Shu]

I like the one with the pokemon (sarcasm). I guess this is the Pokemon - Go radar thing brought me, so I have to vote right?

Herbizarre (#2) has my vote. They are both good to be honest, I just prefer the layering and the font/font color of the graphics. Great job to you both!