Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avatar : 7/10. Nothing special done to it. But I like simplistic avatars, so that's okay. :ryan:

Sig : 8/10. Dark and eerie signatures usually catch my attention more than other kinds, so I thought this was neatly done. Nothing is overdone and it's not too simple. But if I were making it, the slightly glowing edges around her hair would bother me a tad bit, but I see the purpose of them, so it's nothing serious ~

Mini-tag : 7.5/10. I do like how the text contrasts with the rest of the work done. To me, too much of the same color can be a bad thing, but the negative (I'm guessing linear dodge?) effect of the font prevents that from happening. :ryan: That, and gas masks are sweet. :mokken:
​
 
Sig: I have mixed feelings about this. On one part I just love the lighting, but then there's the fact that a part of me thinks it's a weebit simple. Ahh, but I just love the stock used. :gonk: 7.9/10

Avatar: this is very nice. Nothing too fancy, and that is great when it comes to avatars. 8/10
 
The avatar is quite a nice image and I particularly like the butterfly, the nice soft light in the bottom left suits the image. The border is perfect for the icon and accentuates what was already excellent

The signature is also rather a nice piece, however it is not quite as good as the avatar by a long chalk. Once again the pale blue lighting is a well added effect and really highlights the image without smacking you in the face. The right side seems slightly out of joint though and lacking clarity
 
Avatar: 7.5/10. I think you cut it out of the sig at a good point, missing most of the black shroud stuff, I like the picture used.

Signature: 5/10 :( I'm sorry but the black stuff just makes the sig very dull and it takes away all the pretty colours underneath.
 
The avatar is quite nice, the red discs and flare look really well, a nice modest piece. I can't help but wonder if it would look better with normal edges though

The first signature is great in its idea but not execution, at least in my opinion. The top left just doesn't work at all, it just looks really odd and out of place. The text could also have more clarity or contrast. The render is well placed though, the colours suit it well, and the lighting very good. The dots of light and beam are also great additions

One of the closest things I have ever seen to a flawless and perfect piece, there is no point trying to say why it is so great
 
You sure like text pieces. :lew:

It's coolio. Loving the colors, effects - everything is nice. The border really gives it a sense of completion. :ryan: And i give it extra cool point for the bokeh as I am an abuser of Bokeh myself. :lew:

And the avvy is full of lolz, but in a good way. ;)
 
oh you got a new set so I will rate you again.

Avatar: 8/10 I quite like it :grin: it's simple but nice, the colour you used on it is really nice, like a rusty kind of brown but it suits the character.

Signature: 7/10Looks good and I like how it's almost black in colour and the highlights are his face and the coloured orbs in the corners. I think some other kind of text would suit it better though, something crisper. and maybe some form of border, but I do like it :grin:
 
Toni :britt:

Avatar: 10/10
I lvoe the red polka dots and the lighting. The pic is a very nice one, Paul's all like "Hey Toni how are ya...Ready to go with Marlena and Ian?" :lew:

Sig(s): Both 10/10
I love everything about them, there really is nothing wrong with it. If anything the one done by BC has his face a lil grainy (probably just cuz of the pic) but still so perfect ^_^

My Ian one will be put up in a few :britt:
 
rating... awesomness XD

avatar 8/10 it simple.. that it XD

signature 9/10 I love the text on the signature it very nice and the colours are really nice as well :D
 
The signature is not a bad piece at all, the background is quite well done and suits the image you have chosen. The border and image placement are also nicely done, and the text was good choice. The avatar is just a crop so there is no point saying anything else about it

If you have rated my signature, reload the page you king cnut
 
For the avvy, I give it a 7/10. Its very plain, no curved edges or background...and the guy is kinda meh. The batman crop was better in my opinion.

For the sig it landed on the one with the rainbow colors and had bango... something in text. I believe that this was Cali's sig. I like it and I think she did a really good job. I love the coloring and the clairity of the text...and how the text sticks out from the rest of the sig. I'm not crazy about the white boarders with this but I guess its okay. 8.5/10.
 
Last edited:
Okay Mel.

Set: 9/10
There's really nothing wrong with it. Lighting is really nice, and the background fits the image so well. It's a really nice set.

Stella's got her groove on :britt: If that's supposed to be Stella...:lew:
 
Ah you are correct Stella my pal, however he is bitingly funny which is why I chose him

I am not sure what I think about this set truth be told, technically it is very well made. The design is fluid, innovative and the colouring matches the picture perfectly. Despite the fact that I can see it is well made and is a nice set, I do not like it. So yeah, also not mad on that guy

If you have rated my signature, reload the page you king cnut
 
Avatar: who is the guy? but anyway. it's just a pic on a white background. 5/10 because the guy looks koolios.

Siggy: i like a design in the background. the colour fit's nicely making it look really pretty. I like the girl as well. 9/10 because no picture is perfect. Maybe a little more design in it? Because the right side is just bland.
 
That is Simon Amstell he is very cruel, I am surprised you also did not recognise Marilyn Monroe

The avatar is very small and rather blurry, I have no idea what that text says and it reminds me of a 12 year old girl's myspace.

The first signature is very good, the colouring and background goes well with the image. The lighting is a good idea, but far too heavy

This is more difficult to rate, I am unsure if I like or dislike it to be honest. The effects are quite nice and blend well to the image's focal point, though the text could be a little larger. It just seems grimy though overall

If you have rated my signature, reload the page you king cnut
 
8/10 for the tag. My reasons are clear: It has solid snake, and great composition. i do not think there could be any better reasons. :grin:

And the avvy gets automatic 10/10 for Jesse Eisenburg..at least, I'm gonna tell myself that's him. :britt:
 
Deus Ex! <3

The avi gets a nice 9/10. The lighting is just perfect! I can't help but think that maybe a small border or another effect could have made it look even better.

The signature gets a 8/10. I'm really not a fan of the text and it's placement but I do like how it's lighted. The balls of light add a bit of spark to the signaturebut I can't help but feel that the guy in the pic could have been lightened up just a tiny bit more. Overall though it's really great work ^^
 
It is Simon Amstell

The avatar is not bad I guess, the picture is clear and focussed nicely on the image. The effects are subtle without being redundant and mesh nicely with the theme of the piece, it's just not amazing. I don't know why, it just doesn't strike me I guess

The signature, or as you cool cats call it 'tag' has some great ideas going on, the execution isn't stellar though. The diagonal slices on the right side are cool, but they have jaggy edges and and lack clarity. Also, perhaps you should have filled them with more apt pieces of the render. The text is pointless and does not look good in my opinion. The entire tag is grimy and blurry almost, but the underlying effects were a good plan.

If you have rated my signature, reload the page you king cnut
 
Avatar: 6/10, the background is pretty with the orange and stuff, the text is nice and crisp but it's a bit boring.

Sig: The sig I am viewing right now is the one with the dude with the glasses. 10/10. I think it looks really cool. I love the slight hint of purple and the text is really nice, the small white borders really suit it and the picture is well picked. Great job, nothing bad about this piece at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top