Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avatar: 0/10

Nothing there to judge :wacky:

Signature: 9/10
I love the size. I love the pink, yellow, white and red color chosen to be used as well. I love the vectors in the back ground as well, they're really nice. They look almost like a pop-out book does. I love the font placement too, and the color is just gorgeous. I like the yellow flares too. Very nice. I like the render used too but it looks like the original picture was of low quality and I can see it in some places. But it's amazing how well lew covered that up, it looks great.
 
Avatar: 8/10 looks good :grin: nice lighting

Signature: 9/10 again great lighting and I'm loving the background and the text as well.. proper awesome :grin:
 
Because the avatar is a crop of the sig, I will rate them as a set.

9/10 for both. The stock quality is crystal clear and the colors are so vibrant :ohoho: I'm not a huge fan of red, but I think it looks very nice. The delicate lighting effects make this a very well done set. I also really like how the set matches. Good job :ryan:
 
Avatar: 7/10 looks cool, but I don't know who it is :whistle:
Sig: *cough, cough* I'm at work... Not work appropriate... (But 8/10) ;)
 
Avatar: 3/10 Crushed image and low quality :sick:

Sig: 8/10 Much better. Nice text and I like the effects around the Ragnarok.
 
Avatar: 9/10
I love everything about it except the border. :/

Sig: 9/10
The render is really good, I mean REALLY good. I'm liking the red background and the fire-ie affects used. I like the font placement and the actual font. The border isn't one of my favorite kinds to use but it works on this sig. The only... what's with the random phone booth? :lew:
 
Avatar -
8/10, while it's a crop, I like the little gray stripe you have on there.

Signature -
10/10, I hate Nicki Minaj :wacky:. Such vibrant color colors though, And I like the text too. (y) Awesome work.
 
Avvy - 9/10
Love it. the clarity is perfect, and is just great as an avvy.

Sig - 5.6/10
If I may be honest, I like a minority of this tag. That said minority would be the bg effects you have, but I think that's all it has going for it. It's just overall a very boring piece, and if I may add, pretty monotonous. Now, granted I'm not one to talk about monotonous pieces, but I still say it. I also do not like the text at all. I don't know whether it's the font itself or whatever.
 
The avatar is just a crop of the sig sans text, I still absolutely hate it though. That render is absolutely vile and I loathe it with fury of a thousand burning suns. The tag itself is actually very good considering the image it was based around, it would be quite nice without such a horrible render

The Goku piece is less well-made, but approximately a billion times less maddening to look at. The render is slightly overwhelmed with light and the background just kind of looks like a blurry rocks. I am not saying that it did not have loads of work put into the background, but it just looks like it didn't. A nice enough piece of work overall though

Fuck, I hate that puppet
 
Thats one big sig 8( ...either that or its my pc because I have the text and etc zoomed so much :lew:

Anyways :dave: ...since your avatar is a crop of your signature, I will rate them both the same.

I'm giving 8/10 for this set. Its just a little plain for me, however it is well done. Its a little on the dark side, and I like how the character's glowing eyes light it up a bit. The stock is crystal clear as well.
 
Eek! :kira:

Okay, this has got to be one of the most feminine sets on the entire site. I'm digging the pretty barbie-glamor-type render of the blond girl. She adds a really mod touch to the sig. I love the floral vectors in the background. their colors are so pretty against the background. I love how the font is placed but the gradient seems too hard.

Still I love it.

I like the simple crop of the sig as the avatar, too.

9/10 :inlove:
 
sig:
Top sig: 7/10
Nice picture. But I feel that there are too many colours and some parts are too bright. I can't see the arm because of the bubble. But it's good.
Bottom sig: 8/10
It's better, but I don't know who is that >_>
Background colour and the character matches very well. Use of text is also good.

avatar: since it's the same as the sig, I can't say anything else >.< But nice cropping.
 
Sig 1. 8/10. Though I hate that moogle I think the colours and stuff in the signature work really well with it, I like the bubbly effect and the light behind the little guy. Though I like the text I think more could have been done with it.

Avatar + Sig 2: Ehhhhh 4/10. I understand you're new to GFXing. I think you could have used a better picture, the one you used is very blocky and rough, I dunno if that's coz you erased it or something, the colours used are nice though. Keep practicing.
 
The avatar is really great, a good photo that just works perfectly as an icon. Billy Idol is so great :inlove:

The signature is absolutely sublime, phenomenal use of colours and grayscale, though his arm on the right looks weird like a knee now
 
Sig and avatar: 8/10
Very nice signature in action. But maybe should blend the background and the character more. Probably should have less colours involved, IMO. But it is good.

Lol I am addicted to photoshop. But I am a slow learner. The Caius sig was quite a failed attempt. How's my new beginner avatar and sig? (just changed it earlier)
 
3 different things to rate :gasp: !

...okay so for your avatar...I can't say that its my favorite. Its not incredibly clear in quality to me and the colors blend a little too well, so I'm giving this a 7/10.

The first of your sigs I really like. I think Raul did an awesome job. The coloring is so fitting with the moogle and the text matches so well too. While the moogle is overly cute and has been getting a bit of a harsh rap from some, I think he's really cute :lew: 9/10.

For the second of your sigs, I'm not a huge fan of it tbh :( Its very mottled with the coloring, the effects blend too well, and nothing of it particularly sticks out to me. It's nice its just a little on the plain side for me personally. 6/10.
 
Last edited:
I see your wearing this set again? xD I love it. the lens flare is awesome, and with the black and white colors with the hint of red from the flare really adds a great look. the text is coolio.

I rate the set a 8.6/10 ^_^
 
my go

avatar: 8/10 nice effects and the text is cleaver

Signature 1: 9/10 nice signature.. a bit bright (might just be my monitor) but i like it :)

Signature 2: 10/10 beautiful signature blended in really well.. great text and that lighting... god it makes me sooo amazing when i see a signature with lighting like that
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top