- Joined
- Dec 14, 2006
- Messages
- 11,628
- Location
- California
- Gil
- 0
- FFXIV
- Mitsuki Calei
- FFXIV Server
- Lamia
- Free Company
- Gaia
-Threads Merged- I've also included "Other" in the poll as well.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Well I’m an Asatruar
We also honour our ancestors
(and I’m sure my gods are okay with me being okay with that).
If the god that you describe does not interfere with the universe, then he probably matches the description of the god in the Deism religion
And Katsky, let the man believe what he wants =P.
Sorry your new religion is predominately held by neo-Nazis.
I've always been fascinated by logic (or lack thereof) of ancestor worship, why would you worship some corpse you either never met or didn't do anything which would merit worship?
Although I question the idea of worship all together, Hero worship seems more logical.
Why did I just imagine an overweight bearded man sitting on a couch in the clouds, wearing a horned viking helmet with a bag of chips rested on his stomach, flipping the channels on the television? Oh that's right, because the idea of an anthropomorphic God is absurd. How do you believe this?
Kuja
And Katsky , let the man believe what he wants =P.
No, if we let people believe what they want without questioning their reasoning we'd still be in some backwards tribal society full of lunkheads, like Africa.
I thank you for attempting to help me but If I couldn't stand up to people taking this view I wouldn't have been in my religion very long
No matter who you are your ancestors helped shape you life (such as if they moved to another country and your kin have remained there), though we believe this extends to the spiritual side as well. As such we remember them as they are our family (dead or not) and include them in our religious ceremonies (of cores the ones who did damaging things to you family line (such as if you had a mass murderer in your line) are either remembered badly or not at all). Also just because they didn’t save the world from Godzilla doesn’t mean they don’t deserve honouring, many ancestors did nothing more then keep there family under a roof, well fed and clothed and I see no reason not to honour them.
I think our differences lie in the fact that you think you need a reason to honour them I think you need a reason not to.
One god is absurd, how is there only one, have you ever seen any other life form there was only one of, or for that matter why one at all.
If you don’t believe my and many other gods then what’s one more, isn’t he just as absurd as mine?
And also how can you believe in a god that you have no way of understanding?
2: I don’t get the point of the couch potato bit other then to insult me
3: when did I say they where anthropomorphic? They are individuals but I don’t quite believe Thor literally is a bearded man with a hammer.
That is just offensive, not only to me but to Africans.
I will have you know that this lunkhead attended Glasgow University studying Astrophysics and is now beginning his fist year of Marine Science at a marine research facility.
Just because I follow old gods doesn’t mean that I think we should all go back and dress like the Norsemen, have longships and go off a Viking.
Knowledge in my religion is highly valued and we are often criticised for our demand that you learn first and form your own opinions (key word: learn)
I wasn't trying to impy that you were incapable of defending your religion, just that katsky should be a little more open minded to other peoples beliefs.
Is Bill wrong? No, Bill can think whatever he wants.
Do I/Anybody have the right to claim hes wrong, Yes. But we cannot forcibly say hes wrong, but instead keep it to ourselves.
You should never have to honour your family because they're your family, it is a sick idea, and leads to such social issues as spousal and child abuse and even racism, because how far back does your family go? When does it stop? When we became white?
Yeah, I'm sorry if I don't think I should respect an alcoholic cunt who beat the shit out of me when I was young. People, anyone should have to earn your respect, your family should receive no respect by default on their own right.
One law of gravity is absurd, because there are lots of animals there must be separate laws of gravity. Oh lord...
My God isn't a bunch of anthropomorphic bi-curious party animals. It's a force that flows through nature like gravity.
I don't understand a lot about the wind, nor is it visible, doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
I was creating an image to portray the absurdity of anthropomorphism in something like God(s).
I once met physics once, he was a great guy, we watched Scrubs and ate Doritos.
Yeah, because they're totally advanced. They hadn't even invented the wheel, a written alphabet or a basic system of mathematics till the Europeans came. And even when they did come and force them into Christianity, to this day they still believe it without question.
How is he African if he lives in the UK?You called me and Africans lunkhead’s (or more accurately compared me to African lunkheads (and I don’t think any of the ones my family new when we lived there would like your racist tone)) remember that. Well I was defending me as I felt the African comment stands out as the stupid racist generalisation that it is.
I agree but it seems to me that you are the one who needs to question his beliefs.I never said that. I said that if we don't question people's reasoning for belief in whatever system of values, etc... we'd be backwards.
Oh yes, but so was tribal warfare, raping, and burning shit to the ground. These things were also seen as legitimate in the original culture of your religion.
Remember the key word learn?
Oh, I'm close minded because I question his whacky belief system?
Your close minded because you don’t question, just insult.
as I said before “So basically I believe due to my agreement of the morals, my love of the traditions and the lore.”Is Bill wrong to believe in [insert bizarre religion here]? The real question lies in his reasoning for believing it.
The morals being: (NB: these are not laws just the top virtues that are present in the lore and commonly agreed upon (all should be guided by wisdom)
Boldness/ Courage
Truth
Honour
Troth
Self-rule
Guest-Friendliness
Busyship
Self Rule
Perseverance
Please feel free to read the lore and then disagree with me just don’t make it up.
What the hell? How can you forcibly say someone is wrong? Do you beat them over the head with a stick while saying "NO YOU ARE A BAD MAN AND YOU SHOULDN'T BELIEVE THOSE THINGS!"?
You can also insult and shun them into it.
Liquidus Zeromus said:Religious extremism and hatred.
The same goes for dogmatic atheists. "OMG HOW CAN YOU BELIEVE IN A GOD, THAT'S SO STUPID, YOU HAVE NO EVIDENCE FOR IT!!! YOU RETARD!!!!!"
Religion can bring hope.
I also question shaky, outdated pagan beliefs. Thor does not make thunder. That has been disproved by science. Pitiful, really. You have Odin, Zeus, Ra, Jupiter, and so on, all the supposed "Kings of the Gods", and yet all faded into myth. They fail in the face of monotheism.
Ignoring the fact that that you just contradicted yourself. I don’t believe Thor makes thunder (and as I said before I don’t even believe he is literally a big guy with a hammer). I could say that monotheism fails in the face of atheism. If you can believe in one god I fail to see how you can see more then one as “crazy”. I do not believe in the literal meaning of the lore, just that there is meaning there and I would say it is no more outdated or crazy then any monotheistic religion.
Ignoring the fact that that you just contradicted yourself. I don’t believe Thor makes thunder (and as I said before I don’t even believe he is literally a big guy with a hammer). I could say that monotheism fails in the face of atheism. If you can believe in one god I fail to see how you can see more then one as “crazy”. I do not believe in the literal meaning of the lore, just that there is meaning there and I would say it is no more outdated or crazy then any monotheistic religion.
Have you read the bible?…… I have…… People in glass houses.Completely absurd fairy tales..
When have I (or my religion) made claims against science (as I pointed out I am my self a scientist). Our religion is not applicable to science (and vice versa); it is a world view not a complete truth. And have you seen those intelligent design people?especially such pseudo-religious "new age" tripe, in the face of science.
Yes, because superior numbers makes belief = factWhere are your grounds for belief in such? God is worshipped by BILLIONS.
Actually most where killed.Most Norsemen ditched Odin and Thor in the face of monotheism. That says alot.
There is very little superstition in our faith, in fact we often wonder of the superstitious nature of Christians.We have rational explanations for alot of that which was surrounded with superstition. Phenomena which such polytheism tried to answer, but was proved incorrect by science.
I would say only people’s belief didn’t survive the test of time, and as I said before it sits well with me and monotheism doesn’t. Don’t get me wrong I’m not attempting to condemn monotheists and say they should be polytheists just that my belief does not lack validity because you don’t like/ agree with it. I was previously an atheist because I disliked the idea of kneeling/ bowing to a god and offering my self as a servant and I didn’t like the logic that got them to there morals (hell) as well as the idea of an all knowing, infallible god.Why revive a dead, ancient religion, which has not weathered the passage of time well?
I would say a lack of honour for you family (and a warped mind) leads to such things as child abuse, beating your wife .
Also do not slander me! I have never made any claims about race; I am completely against racism. Don’t make stuff up!
That statement makes no sense. It has nothing to do with what I said
So we should be able to measure him then? Like gravity. And maybe you should read about my gods a bit more before speaking.
If your not going to make sensible arguments how do you expect me to take you seriously?
Maybe you should learn more about African culture before making stupid comments.
Also I could use the Japanese as an example with their large belief in Shinto and technological advancement.
You called me and Africans lunkhead’s (or more accurately compared me to African lunkheads (and I don’t think any of the ones my family new when we lived there would like your racist tone)) remember that.
Well I was defending me as I felt the African comment stands out as the stupid racist generalisation that it is.
Remember the key word learn?
The morals being: (NB: these are not laws just the top virtues that are present in the lore and commonly agreed upon (all should be guided by wisdom)
Boldness/ Courage
Truth
Honour
Troth
Self-rule
Guest-Friendliness
Busyship
Self Rule
Perseverance
I don’t believe Thor makes thunder (and as I said before I don’t even believe he is literally a big guy with a hammer).
I could say that monotheism fails in the face of atheism. If you can believe in one god I fail to see how you can see more then one as “crazy”.
I do not believe in the literal meaning of the lore, just that there is meaning there and I would say it is no more outdated or crazy then any monotheistic religion.
Have you read the bible?…… I have…… People in glass houses.
it is a world view not a complete truth
And have you seen those intelligent design people?
Yes, because superior numbers makes belief = fact
Actually most where killed.
There is very little superstition in our faith, in fact we often wonder of the superstitious nature of Christians.
Science has proven things like evolution
Something supernatural could have started the big bang, but it is logically impossible for this thing to have been conscious.
but few of them, including Christianity, bother to question where their Creator came from. Was the Creator created? If so, how or by whom? Or did it just pop into being and immediately want to create things spontaneously? How did it know how to create in the first place? Did someone or something teach it? If so, where did the teacher come from and when did it teach the Creator?